PrincipalsPage the Blog

Shouldn’t Teachers Make More Money?: A Supply and Demand View

on July 9, 2009
Print | Email | Save
Despite the pay, this is the best, most rewarding job I have ever had. I like new teachers also, they brighten the school climate. Carl 34 years...
Despite the pay, this is the best, most rewarding job I have ever had. I like new teachers also, they brighten the school climate. Carl 34 years
on Jul 9, 2009

Why is it that when someone gets their first job in education they are so excited?

As an administrator, I consider one of the best parts of my job is getting the opportunity to hire a brand new teacher. I also think it’s a big responsibility because a teacher hired for the 2009-10 school year may retire sometime around 2044.

By then, God willing, I will be 76 years old and only slightly more senile then I am now. Of course, by then I may not even know how old I am or recognize the fact that I may still be senile. I do know that at my school that will be 8 principals (plus about 14 superintendents) from now, so students and staff will have long forgotten my name (it should be noted that I may have also forgotten my name), but this year's new teachers may still be working with students.

A new teacher looks forward to everything about their first teaching assignment: their new room, their own desk, getting keys to the building, a real paycheck, putting up bulletin boards, possibly even school lunch, and of course their first group of students.

Everything about the experience is positive and upbeat. They have no complaints about their schedule, or who their teaching partner is, or parents not being supportive, or the fact that they think teachers aren’t appreciated enough, or that their paycheck is too small.

A new teacher is open to advice and willing to try different things. There is no talk of “Why change? That’s the way we have always done it.” or “I am not going to use the computers. They will never catch on.”

They are thrilled with the job, their colleagues, the kids and the opportunity to make a difference.

This isn’t to say that veteran teachers don’t feel the same way. Many do and are a credit to education, but others may have begun to take the huge opportunity that we have been given as teachers for granted. Many think they should get paid more, get more respect and appreciation, and maybe... just maybe... work less hours.

But so should doctors, engineers, waitresses, carpenters, and the guy who changes the oil in my truck, and everyone else who works hard for a living for not nearly enough money.

Some people will say, since we work with students and are such a big part of shaping the lives of the future that we should be paid triple what we get now.

I would have taken more money, but I am pretty sure I knew what my teaching salary would be when I was hired. I do recall on more than one occasion as I went through school, a teacher commenting on the fact that they didn’t get paid enough, so I wasn’t shocked when I saw my first paycheck.

But somewhere, supply and demand comes into play. Sure, there are areas where good qualified teachers are hard to come by, but for the most part you can find a group of very good applicants for each open teaching position. If there were 50 candidates for every neurosurgeon job, they probably wouldn’t make as much money as they do now.

It also must be human nature that over time some people begin to focus on the things that aren’t given to us in our profession, and less about what we do get.

New teachers aren’t experienced enough to focus on what is not good about their job; they are too busy looking at the good side — they only see a chance to make a real difference. Maybe we should all take a moment at the start of each school year to reflect on the excitement that new teachers possess and we undoubtedly had at the beginning of our careers.


To read more blog entries by Michael Smith, visit his site PrincipalsPage.com.

 


You may use or reference this story with attribution and a link to
http://www.convergemag.com/blog/principal/Shouldnt-Teachers-Make-More-Money.html


Comments

Add a Comment
Add a Comment
on Jul 9, 2009
Despite the pay, this is the best, most rewarding job I have ever had. I like new teachers also, they brighten the school climate. Carl 34 years
on Jul 14, 2009
Good teachers can work through many adverse conditions, so long as somebody "has their back". But some school principals are more interested in their self-image than they are in the interests of the district, the teacher's students, or the individual teachers. My wife was consistently ranked by former students as the best teacher of their entire academic career, and she is still invited to some of their functions such as graduations and weddings. She wrote the district curriculum for her specialty area and was nominated for statewide recognition. But constant diversions from her primary students and a final backstabbing incident from her principal were enough for her to quit. Keep appreciating and encouraging enthusiastic teachers--your support gives them more energy than you can imagine. But the best teachers won't work for a poor leader even if they were paid six figure salaries.
on Jul 14, 2009
During my teaching career, I failed to keep up financially, even though I improved my own education level and dedicated myself to the kids and the profession. My retirement is pathetic. It didn't keep up over time either. My wife left teaching and became the breadwinner; she joked, "we can only one have one of us in this family teaching." She made more than double what I made by the time I retired. Sorry, but the fact is, teachers should make more, if we want to entice the best into the field.

Top Site Stories

Most Popular
Most Emailed
Most Viewed