College without High School
By Maya Frost
on September 21, 2009
Blake Boles has written a remarkable how-to handbook that is destined to change the lives of young people across North America. In "College Without High School: A Teenager’s Guide to Skipping High School and Going to College," he offers a step-by-step plan to help students envision their best educational experience and make the most of the time they would have spent in high school.
We didn’t have Blake’s book when our youngest daughter was figuring out how to do high school differently. As a freshman, she spent a year as the only foreigner at her high school in Mexico, and then started taking Spanish classes at a local university in Buenos Aires alongside college students from the United States. After a great semester of college courses, enrolling in high school seemed like a huge step backward, so she took advantage of some wonderful opportunities to work with tutors and mentors and then spent a summer in Oregon taking a full load of college courses while preparing for her GED tests. That fall, at 16, she enrolled as a freshman at an American college in Buenos Aires, and the following year, she got a nice scholarship/grant package when she transferred as a junior to a private college in upstate New York at the age of 17. She spent the summer doing an independent research project in Argentina and is excited to complete her BS this December just two weeks after she turns 19.
But that’s just her story. Her three older sisters also pursued alternative routes, and there are many ways to prepare for and get into college without attending high school. Blake’s book is full of tips and stories to help students plot their own best path.
I had the chance to interview Blake between his sessions leading the Not Back to School Camp for teens. He shared some thoughts about the book.
You had an epiphany in college while majoring in astrophysics. Tell us about that and where it led you.
Since early in high school, I had a passion for physics. Getting high grades in my math and science classes and watching the movie “Contact” also nudged me in that direction. So, I entered UC Berkeley under the astrophysics major and studied it diligently for two years. It was in my third year that cracks started forming in the edifice. In quantum physics, I started to see that astrophysics was really just hardcore math, and I began to question my motivations for becoming a professional astronomer. Luckily, that same semester, a friend from a one-unit elective class handed me a book by famed public-school-teacher-turned-homeschool-advocate John Taylor Gatto.
Like a chainsaw, Gatto quickly cut through every assumption I held about the necessity and benefits of regular public schooling. I consumed his book in three days and immediately did a Google search for related authors, which led me to Grace Llewellyn, The Sudbury Valley School, Summerhill and John Holt. Within two weeks, I saw that my passion for astrophysics, genuine but faltering, was no match for the immense intellectual curiosity I held for alternative education. I scoured Berkeley for a design-your-own-major option, argued and pleaded, and eventually got my way. For the next two years, I studied alternative education exclusively, following a plan of my design. My curriculum included volunteering at a local “free school,” reading Gatto’s gigantic "Underground History of American Education," taking numerous upper division education courses, and designing and leading my own elective course for undergrads (entitled “Never Taught to Learn”). The intellectual and emotional high that I derived from self-directing my college studies was the major epiphany of my young adulthood, and it set the foundation for later writing "College without High School."
What advice can you give to students who have parents who remain unconvinced of this alternative path to a college degree?
Parents should be rightly skeptical of anyone peddling college admissions snake oil — there’s a lot out there. My ultimate response to skepticism is: Look at the evidence. Look at MIT or Stanford’s online admissions guidelines for homeschoolers. They don’t want high school diplomas. They don’t want some perfect equivalent of four years of high school classes. They want teens who have taken personal initiative and designed meaningful, independence-building activities for themselves. They want teens who have boldly explored the realms of business, international travel and college-level research prior to convincing themselves that they actually need college. Traditional high school is very often a handicap in pursuing these character traits. And while not every college has explicit homeschool admissions policies like MIT and Stanford, the logic remains the same: Colleges want dynamic, innovative teens who leave the cookie-cutter approach behind for greener pastures.
Skeptical parents often compare their child’s college preparatory journey to their same journey of yesteryear. It’s important to realize that high school diplomas don’t hold nearly the same cachet today as they did a few decades ago. Community colleges are much easier to get into as a teen, and dual- or early-enrollment programs abound. The biggest bureaucratic hurdles exist in public college admissions, but an easily obtained GED can soothe those ruffled feathers. These facts are the kind of evidence that parents should seek out to decide whether their fears are founded or unfounded.
What tips do you offer to students who have been in public or private schools through the eighth or ninth grade and are now considering preparing for college without high school?
My book is actually written for just those teens: the ones who have attempted to diligently follow school’s path but have only met disillusionment and boredom in the process. (Middle school is usually when this sets in.) A majority of the teens interviewed in my book made their unschooling decision in ninth grade.
What’s most important for a teen making the transition away from traditional school is to identify, as specifically as possible, their personal dreams and goals. Read the books that have always caught your eye in the bookstore. Take the train to visit your friend three states away. Build a computer in your garage or spend six hours a day writing music. Unschooling should be a “moving toward” something, not “moving away.” Once these values are clear, they should start pursuing them ruthlessly — and then figure out how college prep can be mixed into the brew. Following this order (interests first, college prep second) is vital for maintaining enthusiasm and self motivation as an unschooler.
If a teen doesn’t know what truly excites them (as often happens with first-time school refugees), a short deschooling vacation might be in order. This is a period of time during which no structured academics are required, no schedule is followed and parental nudging is kept to a minimum. The point is for the teen to push through the no-one-is-going-to-tell-me-what-to-do barrier and enter I-have-to-motivate-myself land.
Though you encourage students to get creative about designing a personalized college-prep education, you suggest they prepare for and take standardized tests such as the SAT or AP tests. Why not continue their alternative approach by finding other options for admission?
The SAT is certainly not required for all college admissions as a homeschooler, but the vast majority of traditional schools require at least one traditional academic achievement indicator (SAT, ACT, GED) and often more (SAT Subject, AP). The good news is that these tests have always existed independently of high school, and for that reason, it’s easy to prepare for them as a homeschooler. Grab a few SAT study guides, figure out exactly where your weak spots are, review hard in those areas and take the test when you see fit. It's a self-directed and results-oriented approach to college prep.
In view of the financial challenges facing many families, what’s your advice for those who need to reduce their college costs?
Community college is a golden bullet for financial hurdles. Many of the college-bound unschoolers with whom I work start community college around age 16, gather a significant number of transferable credits (or an associate's degree) by 18 or 19, and have lots of cool adventures along the way. Then they're ready to apply (or transfer) into a four-year school with sophomore or junior standing, saving thousands or tens of thousands of dollars.
What options do you recommend for those interested in increasing their knowledge of the world and themselves?
As you argue excellently in "The New Global Student," international immersion provides teens with an incredible wealth of self-knowledge. But many teens don't want to participate in a packaged tourist program that carefully clings to the beaten path, and many parents won't let their teens leave the beaten path alone. The solution lies somewhere in the middle — in finding a program that provides some modicum of safety and structure while providing teens with ample time to explore a new culture and learn from the common travel mistakes that they'll inevitably make.
To find such opportunities, I recommend that teens first explore Idealist.org and search for volunteer positions specific to their age and desired location (using the "advanced search" feature). Often these programs provide a host family, English-speaking support network, and both structured and unstructured time. Another option (for those who don't mind getting their hands dirty) is WWOOF: World-Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms. In exchange for a small number of hours of farm work each day, students get to enjoy total immersion in the rural life of a foreign country. Both volunteering and "WWOOFing" offer the coveted combination of low cost and high immersion that a globetrotting teen seeks. There are also, of course, my own Unschool Adventures and Homeschool Leadership Retreats that strive to offer a similar experience.
I highly recommend Blake’s book to any middle school or high school student seeking more excitement and engagement in their educational journey. Smart parents should buy this book for their kids and be bold enough to encourage them to forge ahead in new ways.
To read more blog entries by Maya Frost, visit her site MayaFrost.com.